I prefer to write with a fresh, rested mind. A state in which phrases flow freely, fingers doing their best to dance across the keyboard.
It feels perverse to be forcing myself, in this morning’s fuzzy state, to describe the circumstances that brought me to this place. Dragging words out of foggy corners of my brain; wrestling them into order.
It began yesterday morning with a call from Andrea, “Please would you take my place at tonight’s Bordeaux tasting.” It was more instruction than request.
With a tasting line-up consisting of eight wines from the 2001 vintage, followed by more of the same to accompany a fabulous dinner at Beyond restaurant (on Buitenverwachting), how could I refuse?
Meekly, I proffered, “I’ll have a hangover tomorrow.” Ever since dropping wine for half the week, midway through 2024, and moderating my consumption on the days that I do imbibe, to a couple of glasses, I’ve turned into a lightweight. My body just doesn’t metabolise alcohol the way it used to.
“Yes, but it will be worth it.”
Knowing that there would be two First Growths in the line-up, I resigned myself to a pleasurable path that would have unpleasant consequences.
I moved onto the logistics of the rest of the afternoon and evening.
The first order of business was leaving Ashton around midday to drive to Paarl where I’d be attending the viewing of two Thoroughbred stallions. In retrospect, this gathering had much in common with the Bordeaux tasting that would follow later.
In the case of the equine gathering, professionals look at the stallions with a view to deciding whether to send their mares to be covered by those stallions. While there may be overlap in their opinions, it remains subjective. There is no empirical measurement of a horse’s good looks, nor any way of knowing for sure whether the stallion will imbue his progeny with any excellence. Difference of opinion is the order of the day.
From the time a stallion covers his first mares, it’s over three years before the first foals start racing. It’s at least five to seven years before a fair assessment can be made of his ability as a stallion. This is not that dissimilar to en primeur purchases of Bordeaux, in that the true quality will only be known years hence.
However, this part of the afternoon took much longer than expected. I was going to be under major time pressure to get to the tasting on time.
I arrived home at the time that I would have to leave. Having spent all afternoon driving, I liked the idea of relaxing in the back of an Uber on the way to Beyond.
Fortunately, the Uber was quick in arriving; I was doing up the buttons on a fresh shirt as I ran down the driveway, jacket flapping in the wind.
By the time the Uber drove onto Buitenverwachting, evening sun setting on the vineyards, I’d put four hours of driving behind me. I was ready for great wine.
Before I get to the wine, I need to give full kudos to the organisers/hosts of the evening, Wine Cellar, as well as the venue and its staff. All of this was excellent. So too, Johan Malan’s presentation that accompanied the tasting.
After welcome glasses of Champagne, the group of 20 was seated around one large table. Each place was set with two rows of four tasting glasses, the gleaming expanse of the table unsullied by the placement of spittoons. Interestingly, there were two fathers and sons, the youngest of whom was born after 2001. We all must do our bit to develop the wine lovers of the future!
The balance of the group comprised knowledgeable amateurs, at least one WSET student, as well as my friends Dave and John. Dave has certainly tasted more wine than any of the other attendees, whilst John has the most years of enjoying fine wine.
I’m the ex-professional, but with a palate that jumps into action any time I have wine in my glass. A bit like muscle memory, I suppose.
It was a treat and a privilege to taste this line-up of generally excellent 25-year-old wines. I loved the combination of elegance and fruit concentration in the best of them. I think we need these types of reference points, even if they come at cost that is many multiples of what we drink on a regular basis.
Few wines get to 25 years of age while still delivering this much joy.
Unfortunately, I was underwhelmed by the Haut-Brion, which was not only overshadowed by the other First Growth that followed (Latour), but also by some of the smaller wines. To my taste, it was unbalanced, with very dry tannins and finishing short.
When comments were called for, I felt the need to express my opinion. If there is a First Amendment that applies to wine tastings, I would hope that alcohol is regarded as a mitigating factor. However, I’m not sure that the other tasters were appreciative of having a Grinch in their midst.
John and Dave, sitting beside me, were also dissenters on some of the wines. I imagined the three of us sitting in a version of Graham Norton’s red chair, getting pitched into the darkness in retribution for not being in lockstep adulation for these vaunted wines.
The Latour was an obvious high point, delivering on its promise as a First Growth. Ticking a bunch of boxes, the Léoville Las Cases didn’t taste like a wine that’s a third of the price. Similarly, the Clerc Milon, which is less than a quarter of the price of Latour. Both of these punched way above their price points.
‘Drinking wine’ during dinner flowed liberally and included a surprise addition: the 2001 Kanonkop Cabernet Sauvignon, which was remarkably fresh for its age.
I could have had several more glasses of the Canon (from magnum) that was generously poured with main course, but I would have been in even worse condition today if I had.
In the latter part of the evening, I got chatting to the fund manager to my left. As so often happens, when he heard of my involvement in horse racing, he made a pointed reference to Markus Jooste, with a little chuckle. He said something about the many people in the investment community who were taken in by him.
I strayed into some name dropping, mentioning friends in the industry who had been Steinhoff sceptics. Calling bullshit is tough at the best of times, and even harder when there’s a cult involved, as there was around Jooste.
The very high prices attached to the world’s most in-demand wines suggest that there are cultish effects at play.
For a glass of Clerc Milon (by way of example), I’ll happily declare myself a member of that cult, but allow me to call bullshit when required. Just because a wine has a particular denomination or heritage doesn’t mean one is obliged to either admire or like what is in the glass. Sometimes it just doesn’t live up to either status or expectation. Unfortunately, it’s occasionally a single bottle that’s not in pristine condition.
I’m one of many people around the world who is drinking less. Time will tell what impact this has on the production of top tier wines. Perhaps being the focal point of a cult – even in an informal sense – will protect that heritage.
Wine appreciation is beyond the reaches of AI, which is a further reason to protect it.
Wine drinking doesn’t often comprise a blow-out evening like last night. Indeed, my preference is to save myself for measured drinking experiences that I can cherish. I’m here to do my bit to support the industry, even if it means that occasionally, I – literally – put my body on the line, as I have in the past 24 hours.
By tomorrow I’ll have forgotten how I felt today, but the unique expression of Cabernet Sauvignon & Co. as grown in the best parts of Bordeaux and aged for 25 years will remain a treasured memory.
(It seems appropriate to share one of my favourite pieces of writing about wine, Cal Fussman’s article that was published in Esquire: Cocktails Before the Collapse)
The tasting line-up:
Branaire Ducru, Saint-Julien 2001 (4e Cru Classé)
Haut Bailly, Pessac-Léognan Rouge 2001 (Cru Classé de Graves)
Rauzan Ségla, Margaux 2001 (2e Cru Classé)
Clerc Milon, Pauillac 2001 (5e Cru Classé)
Pichon Comtesse, Pauillac 2001 (2e Cru Classé)
Léoville-Las Cases, Saint-Julien 2001 (2e Cru Classé)
Haut-Brion, Pessac-Léognan 2001 (1er Cru Classé)
Latour, Pauillac 2001 (1er Cru Classé)
With dinner:
Canon, Saint-Émilion 2001 (magnum) (Premier Grand Cru Classé “B”)
Pavillon Rouge du Château Margaux, Margaux 2001 (3 litre)
Doisy Védrines, Barsac 2001 (2e Cru Classé)